The Acupuncture Evidence Project examines the question ‘Is acupuncture even better than we think it is?’
Extract from The Acupuncture Evidence Project
‘It has been observed from the over 8,000 randomised controlled trials which appear in the Cochrane Database of Controlled Clinical Trials that, in studies where acupuncture is compared with no treatment, wait list or usual care, there is a significantly larger treatment effect than when acupuncture is compared with some form of sham, placebo or minimal acupuncture. The Society for Acupuncture Research has dubbed this phenomenon a paradox in acupuncture.
‘There is evidence that many, if not all, the forms of sham/placebo acupuncture treatment protocols used in acupuncture trials to date are not inert, and exert physiological, and possibly also placebo effects, making it extremely difficult (if not impossible) to accurately measure how much of the observed non-specific effects may be attributable to placebo and/or nocebo effects, and how much is due to the placebo not being inert. Hence a comparison of the effect size of acupuncture when compared to that of placebo acupuncture may result in consistent underestimation of the true effect size. Some acupuncture researchers are now suggesting that clinical decisions
Credit: Wellcome Library, London. Wellcome Images
‘regarding whether or not acupuncture should be recommended as a treatment option would be more accurately based on comparisons of acupuncture with usual care or acupuncture with other interventions (head-to-head studies and network meta-analyses). This trend of increased focus on pragmatic trials over explanatory trials is not limited to research into acupuncture, but has been identified as an issue in health research more generally.
Further research recommended
‘Further research on acupuncture mechanisms has also been recommended by both the Society for Acupuncture Research and the National Institutes for Health (NIH) in the USA which, at the Society for Acupuncture Research’s biannual conference in Boston in October 2015, announced a new funding pool dedicated to acupuncture mechanism research. NIH have identified limited value in true versus sham acupuncture trials when investigating pain and have consigned such trials to a low programmatic priority. NIH has given high priority instead to pragmatic studies investigating acupuncture and pain management along with further research into the mechanisms of acupuncture.
‘The use of exit-debrief questionnaires in published sham/placebo-controlled acupuncture trials, which show no significant differences between the real and sham acupuncture groups in belief about which treatment they had received, suggests that in these trials placebo/nocebo effects are not an adequate explanation for any effects produced in the sham acupuncture group.’
(extract from The Acupuncture Evidence Project, 2017)
Is acupuncture even better than we think?
The above extract says that acupuncture’s benefits have been difficult to assess accurately. This is because using sham acupuncture as a placebo has distorted the results of trials. Sham acupuncture often involves the inserting a needle, and this elicits a pain-relieving reaction as true acupuncture would.
This is a very exciting development for acupuncture. It means that previous theories of acupuncture being an elaborate ritual to achieve only a placebo response are inaccurate. Research on acupuncture can now take a fairer, more scientific approach. This suggests that fairer studies will show that acupuncture is even better than we think. Pragmatic trials comparing acupuncture to other treatments are likely to show that acupuncture is far more than just a placebo. As we are beginning to see in many cases, acupuncture can be even better than current medical treatment.