Another huge research piece – the Acupuncture Evidence Project – has just come out of Australia. It is the most comprehensive piece of research for the overall effectiveness of acupuncture to date. This comprehensive acupuncture research builds on previous reports from Australian (2010) and American (2014) departments of veterans’ affairs.
It is considered an ‘over-review’, a review of reviews if you will, where systematic reviews and meta-analyses are combined and compared to produce the most robust and highest level of evidence available.
The researchers analysed 122 conditions to see whether or not the research showed acupuncture to be both clinically and economically effective.
The comprehensive acupuncture research stated that 8 conditions have a positive benefit from acpuncture. A further 38 were likely to have a positive effect, i.e. the reviews this study analyses deemed the evidence good, but insufficient to draw definitive conclusions. Another 71 conditions showed some positive signs but the evidence was insufficient. The remaining 5 conditions did not have enough evidence to show positive effects. The research also shows 10 conditions where acupuncture is cost-effective. What was most exciting is that since the previous over-reviews, 24 conditions have moved up the ranks of effectiveness. In other words, the more research conducted into acupuncture the more effective it is realised to be and for a wider area of action.
Two interesting statements stand out. Firstly, ‘It is no longer possible to say that the effectiveness of acupuncture can be attributed to the placebo effect or that it is useful only for musculoskeletal pain’. This is great news for acupuncturists and patients around the world.
Secondly, ‘The findings of this review are limited by the mounting evidence that sham/placebo controls used in acupuncture trials are not inert, which is likely to lead to a consistent underestimation of the true effect size of acupuncture interventions.’ This means that ‘sham acupuncture’ still works, mildly, in the same way that real acupuncture does, and so is not a fair control. So it could be the case that even more of the conditions would show higher levels of effectiveness in a more accurate study. A fairer control could be a true placebo or standard medical treatment.
Comprehensive acupuncture research covers the following conditions
In case you were wondering, the highest level of evidence was for:
- allergic rhinitis
- back pain (chronic)
- headache (tension type, chronic) and migraine
- knee osteoarthritis
- nausea and vomiting (either post-operative or due to chemotherapy)
- post-operative pain
Again this is a huge study, so I will delve into it more over the next few weeks. For now, I will leave you with one last quote.
‘This project sets a new benchmark to inform acupuncturists, the public, researchers, health departments, governments, and other health providers that acupuncture has a valuable contribution to make to global healthcare and to assist in reducing the global burden of disease.’
To see the full paper (81 pages) click here