Acupuncture is based upon the theories of Chinese medicine, which is rooted in the practical philosophy of Daoism. How does acupuncture work according to Chinese medicine?
Acpuncture is all about harmony and balance: of the yin and yang. Chinese medicine identifies three treasures: Blood and qi, Mind and Essence, and five phases: Earth, Metal, Water, Wood, Fire.
Theory of harmony and balance
This sounds at first like a rather simplistic interpretation of the human system, but each of these categories breaks down in increasing depth and details. For example, each phase represents an organ system, its paired organ, such as Spleen, Stomach, Liver, or Gallbladder, and all the organ’s functions and attributes. Each phase also correlates to a tissue such as muscles or tendons, a sensory organ such as the eye, foods that will benefit and weaken it, colours, seasons, times of day and how it boosts or reduces other phases.
Understanding the categories and their correlates makes some of the terminology used in Chinese medicine easy to grasp intuitively. When we think of heat, for example, it is easy to imagine inflammation, warmth, reddening, dryness and pain. Identifying heat in the intestines therefore suggests an inflammatory gut issue, such as Inflammatory Bowel Syndrome (IBS). But how does acupuncture work in treating these conditions?
Treatment
Acupuncturists first diagnose the problem and then look at the meridian system. They use a highly detailed and complex map of the body. They based the map on the concept that the qi/energy is the animating factor that causes the functioning of the system. Therefore blocked, excessive or weakened energy in certain areas can be treated by correcting these imbalances. Acupuncture aims to restore the balance within the system and return the patient to optimal health and wellbeing.
Acupuncture chart, stomach channel
Credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Acupuncturists insert needles into the relevant acupoints on the meridians that they identify as out of balance. This generally involves placing several needles locally near the affected area and several more on some distal systemic points, elsewhere on the body.
For example, returning to the IBS example, I would use a cluster of needles on the abdomen, to reduce inflammation and increase qi and blood flow in the area. I would also insert a few needles in the arms and legs, choosing points according to the patient’s individual presentation. The arms carry distal points for the large and small intestine, and the stomach and spleen meridians are on the legs. I would therefore do several distal points to calm the intestines and boost the digestive system (stomach and spleen) in order to reduce the inflammation, calm the gut and strengthen the digestive system and reduce the chance of further issues.
Lifestyle factors
Chinese medicine focuses equally on the symptoms and the root of the illness. I therefore look at dietary and lifestyle issues that could be causing or worsening the issue. I advise my patients on any lifestyle changes that they can make to aid recovery and improve their health and wellbeing .
It’s enjoyable for me to share my understanding of Chinese medicine with patients. But I do understand that this language and way of looking at health and wellbeing is unfamiliar, and very unstructured, from a Western medicinal perspective. We are familiar with reductionist science with its specificity and minute detail. So, what does our scientific research say about acupuncture? Does it offer any theories on how acupuncture works?
How does acupuncture work according to Western medicine?
The NHS suggests that acupuncture works by releasing endorphins, which are natural pain killers, when needles are inserted. The British Acupuncture Council goes a bit further, stating, ‘The insertion of needles has an effect on nerves which can release muscles, over-ride brain signals, and so on. There are very often chemical changes in body fluids associated with treatment. Experimentation on animals aims to show how various hormones and neurotransmitters are affected’. In other words, inserting needles changes the chemicals that the body’s systems release, promoting a harmonious balance. For example, acupuncture may work by downregulating overactive immune systems or upregulating underactive ones.
One way to illustrate this is to imagine a trauma: a cut or bruise. When this occurs, the immune system floods the area to try and heal it, reduce pain, prevent infection etc. Acupuncture perhaps works as a micro-trauma. Reminding the immune system that there is an issue in a particular area could stimulate a healing response. However, this does not explain distal mechanisms, for example a practitioner putting a point in the leg to affect the digestive system.
Research studies
Studies show that radioactive isotopes injected into acupoints rapidly disperse along meridian lines, while those injected into random points just disperse locally. An old piece of research also shows that stimulation of a point on the lower leg associated with the eye stimulated the visual cortex of the brain. So although we do not yet fully understand how acupuncture works, there are observable changes that support Chinese medical theory.
We are still a long way from understanding how acupuncture works. We are still working to reconcile different approaches to medicine from allopathic/Western and Chinese/Eastern perspectives. Even so, thousands of years of evidence show that acupuncture and Chinese herbal medicine are useful, effective, and safe for a wide variety of conditions. Furthermore, the research carried out so far on acupuncture and herbal medicine validates Chinese medical theory from a Western perspective. But we still need to study all aspects of acupuncture deeply and fully understand its mechanisms. Until then, it will be hard to answer the question of exactly how acupuncture works.
I hope you found that interesting. As always, please do get in touch if you have any questions or would like to try acupuncture for yourself.